The Challenges Facing Community Transport Operators

Apr 16, 2024 | Community Transport

Each day, community transport services thread through our busy towns and cities, ever integral, yet fragile. Community transport operators are the champions of mobility and connectivity for many, yet each day confronted with an array of challenges that continue to impact their essential and often undervalued services.

Beneath the surface of this humble and often thankless dedication, lies a struggle for survival in a lot of cases. At the heart of community transport—its funding—is under siege, with operators scrambling for grants and donations.

For the volunteers and volunteer drivers, who are the backbone of this sector, burnout is growing due to the ever-growing demand for transport – rising in part due to non-emergency patient transport (NEPT) being passed onto community transport services from traditional ambulances.

This article explores the challenges facing community transport and what is being done to help them.

Challenges in Funding

Community transport operators play a crucial role in providing access to essential services, especially in rural communities where public transport is sparse or non-existent.

These beneficial community transport schemes and community organisations enable passengers to:

  • attend crucial health appointments and treatments,
  • maintain social connections,
  • access to education,
  • and remain connected to their community,

Lack of financial support for community transport operators

Despite their integral role, community transport operators consistently wrestle with limited financial backing. This scarcity of funds halts their capability to scale services to answer the growing demands of an ageing population and the ever-growing need for rural mobility solutions.

As a result, critical service gaps emerge, rendering isolated populations without reliable transport options.

Compounding this issue is the chronic underfunding, reflecting a persistent undervaluing of the sector, where community buses and dial-a-ride services run on shoestring budgets when compared to their public transport counterparts.

Limited funding sources for community transport services

Community transport providers are hindered not just by the deficiency in funds, but also by the limited nature of funding sources available.

Notable instances of this shortfall include the insufficiency of financial support for vital community transport initiatives.

As community transport operators are often not recognised under certain legal guidelines, they miss out on potential resources that could bolster their operations.

Reliance on grants and donations for sustainability

Often reliant on the goodwill of external sources, community transport services must rely on grants and donations for their continued existence. This reliance underlines a lack of systemic support for a sector fulfilling an essential public function.

Securing financial assistance is particularly poignant for adaptability concerns, such as procuring and retrofitting Electric Vehicles to ensure continued service in increasingly eco-conscious times.

Competition with profit-driven sectors for funding

Another significant hurdle facing community transport is the competition with profit-driven transportation sectors.

In these sectors, financial incentives are more appealing, drawing away potential staff and funds. The community transport sector’s dedication to service over profit puts them at a disadvantage, unable to muster the same financial magnetism to attract drivers and investment.

Furthermore, funding cuts have placed added strain on community bus services, in some cases leading to drastic budget constraints that jeopardize the future of these schemes.

To secure the future of community transport—a lifeline for many—there is a pressing need for reevaluated funding strategies and greater recognition of the sector’s indispensable services.

Staffing Issues

community transport staffing issues

As discussed already, community transport services play a vital role in ensuring that vulnerable populations, particularly in rural communities, have access to medical appointments, essential services, and social events.

Yet, these services face an array of staffing issues that can hinder their operations and impact the quality of support they deliver to community members.

Difficulty in attracting and retaining volunteers for driving and administrative roles

Community transport operators depend heavily on the goodwill of volunteers to function, with driving and administrative roles forming the backbone of these community transport schemes.

The challenge, however, lies in attracting and retaining these community transport drivers and volunteers, notably the drivers, but also in attracting the right kind of people to the role, people who are understanding, empathetic and caring by nature.

Recommended:
Podcast: The Value of Community Transport with David Squires

Given the substantial time commitment required for these positions, many community transport services struggle to fill their rosters.

The nature of the volunteer sector, which mainly includes retirees, poses a unique dilemma as they are more available during weekdays, leaving gaps in service during evenings and weekends.

Administrative roles require an equally dedicated commitment, as coordinators juggle the complexities of matching passengers with volunteer drivers and handling the operational logistics.

The informal nature of many community bus service operations can also deter potential volunteers who may seek more structured environments or clearer role definitions.

As such, community transport initiatives often find themselves in a cycle of continuous recruitment, which strains both resources and existing staff.

Challenges facing community transport include a lack of resources to provide training and support for volunteer drivers

Community transport services run on a foundation of care labour — a type of labour that is historically undervalued and underpaid. This has direct implications for resource allocation, particularly in the training and support of volunteer drivers who often drive in their own private vehicles.

Whilst drivers will most often claim back their mileage at 45p a mile (under 10,000 miles and 25p thereafter), they will not often be paid for their time.

The fragmented nature of community transport regulations and authorities adds to the challenge by creating inconsistencies in training standards and availability.

Funding limitations compound these problems, as inadequate financial support often results in a limiting number of training programs essential for the safety and competence of volunteer drivers.

Without adequate training and support, community transport volunteers may feel ill-equipped to handle the demands of their roles, potentially jeopardising the quality of service and increasing the risk of services being disrupted should volunteers choose to leave.

Potential Staff Burnout and High Turnover Due to the Demanding Nature of Community Transport Work

The demanding and caring nature of community transport work poses a risk of burnout among staff members and community transport coordinators. Dealing with vulnerable groups like older adults, people with disabilities, and those with low incomes can be emotionally and physically taxing.

Burnout is exacerbated by a general undervaluation, leaving volunteers and staff feeling underappreciated despite their skilled labour.

This undervaluation, combined with the demands of the job, can lead to high turnover rates in the sector.

Addressing staff burnout is not only vital to the well-being of the employees but also to the continued functioning and reliability of community transport services, which are indispensable to many community members.

Dependence on a small number of dedicated coordinators to manage operations

The organisational structure of many community transport services is reliant on a limited number of dedicated coordinators.

These individuals are paramount to the success of operations, often managing the intricacies of matching, scheduling, and overseeing service provision under informal financial environments.

Coordinators must also navigate funding sources and regulatory landscapes, which can be vast and complex.

Financial uncertainty can place undue pressure on these individuals, underscoring the fragility of the sector and the need for stable support systems.

The operational efficiency and longevity of community minibuses and VCSs (Voluntary and Community Sectors) depend substantially on the sustained effort and resourcefulness of these key coordinators.

Safety Concerns

community transport safety concerns

Safety concerns are a paramount consideration for community transport operators, who are primarily responsible for the transport needs of some of the most vulnerable members of society.

These passengers often include the elderly, people with disabilities, and those with other protected characteristics, all of whom may face significant barriers when accessing public transport.

Particularly alarming are the issues raised around the use of taxis and private hire vehicles. Vulnerable individuals may feel insecure when using these methods of transport, especially at remote bus or rail stations that are unstaffed, or when travelling alone.

Both physical safety and well-being must be prioritised to ensure that these passengers can trust and rely on community transport operators for their mobility needs.

The psychological implications of losing mobility are profound.

Recommended:
Community Transport: Everything You Need to Know

It’s not just about being able to go from point A to point B; mobility affects life satisfaction, happiness, and self-perception, all of which are critical for overall well-being, especially for older adults.

Community transport services must ensure that individuals feel secure not just during their ride, but also during the first and last mile of their journey, which often involves transitioning between different modes of transportation.

Risk of accidents and incidents on busy roads and challenging routes

Navigating busy roads and challenging routes introduces a considerable risk of accidents and incidents, including the potential for vehicle fires emphasizing the importance of preparedness and training to evacuate passengers safely.

For community transport users, particularly those who are vulnerable, such as the elderly, safety concerns do not end with the community transport vehicle.

They extend to the onward journey, potentially in taxis or private hire vehicles from public transport hubs, where the risks and barriers of travelling, especially on their own, can be quite daunting.

These concerns illustrate the critical nature of having disaster preparedness plans for emergencies on challenging routes, despite the relative rarity of incidents like vehicle fires.

Safety is not solely a practical matter but interlinked with psychological well-being too.

The perceived security and ability to navigate with confidence can have a significant impact on the psychological health of community transport service users.

Importance of maintaining and inspecting community transport vehicles for safety

Regular and thorough maintenance and inspections of community transport vehicles are non-negotiable for operators.

This is essential for providing safe, reliable transportation services to vulnerable and isolated individuals who rely heavily on these services for their day-to-day activities.

Properly maintained vehicles are less likely to suffer breakdowns, which can cause delays and disrupt the provision of services.

This is of particular importance for passengers who depend on these vehicles for attending health appointments or other time-sensitive engagements.

A steadfast maintenance and inspection routine instils a level of trust and confidence amongst users of community transport services. It demonstrates a commitment to their safety and the overall integrity of the service, further cementing the operator’s reputation within the community.

Lack of communication and coordination between different community transport operators

Efficient operations within the community transport sector depend on effective communication and collaboration between councils, different transport operators and hospital trusts.

Not only should there be a streamlined approach to the sharing of resources and information, but also a concerted effort to integrate community transport services into broader transportation and healthcare frameworks.

While financial support is crucial for all community transport schemes, it is equally important not just for the transportation services per se but also for supporting the administrative duties that enable these schemes to function seamlessly.

Community transport operators and volunteers should also recognise the limits of their capacity, ensuring that services are sustainable and that the sector does not become overextended, compromising its ability to meet local transport needs.  This is one of the key challenges facing community transport as balancing demand to supply is a constant balancing act without systems and procedures in place.

Road congestion and traffic delays impact timely transport services

Road congestion and traffic delays are additional adverse factors that significantly impact the reliability of community transport services.

These services seek to provide timely and essential transport, which is especially crucial for vulnerable individuals who need punctual rides to important appointments or social engagements.

In several cities, informal transport services add to the problem of congestion, further highlighting the need for a more cohesive and organised approach to community transport.

A fragmented system does not just cause delays but can also complicate the logistics of serving isolated and disadvantaged individuals who depend on these services.

In areas like Northern Ireland, the importance of community transport for addressing both social and transport needs cannot be overstated.

Yet, the systemic issue of road congestion and traffic delays poses a significant threat to the effectiveness of these services, emphasising the need for initiatives aimed at reducing congestion and improving the flow of traffic to facilitate better community transport operations.

Recommended:
Volunteer Driver Mileage Allowances

Legal and Regulatory Compliance

compliance - community transport

Community transport operators, integral to the fabric of public transport, particularly in rural communities and for vulnerable individuals, face ongoing challenges in adhering to legal and regulatory compliance.

They must constantly upgrade their emergency protocols and knowledge base in light of the latest safety standards to ensure the well-being of their passengers.

One such critical area is the recognition and handling of vehicle fires.

Last year there were a reported 19,256 vehicle fires reported in the UK, which underscores the importance of being well-versed in managing vehicle defects that could lead to fire incidents.

The Community Transport Association and similar organizations offer training programs like “5 Steps to Safety” that empower operators by providing them the tools to recognize common fire causes, mitigate fire risks, and proficiently evacuate passengers in emergencies.

Such training sessions involve realistic simulations, including practising evacuation from a smoke-filled minibus, which is vital in preparing operators for real-life incidents.

With evolving technology and the expanding realm of community transport services, maintaining legal and regulatory standards is paramount to sustaining safety and quality.

Compliance is not a mere formality but a foundation upon which the trust between the community and the service providers is built.

This compliance encompasses transportation regulations, licensing requirements, and health and safety protocols, all of which are fundamental for community transport operators to address the multitude of risks and vulnerabilities associated with their services.

Compliance with transport regulations and licensing requirements

Navigating the regulatory landscape, community transport operators must align with the stipulations outlined in the Transport Act 1985.

They often operate within a light-touch framework, utilising Section 19 and Section 22 permits, which authorise non-profit-making bodies and community groups to provide transport for their members or those they serve.

For community minibuses, this regulatory context provides structure and clarity; however, voluntary and community services (VCSs) often face lesser formal regulations compared to minibuses.

The diversity and inconsistency in funding sources for these schemes reflect the less formal financial nature of community transport operations, further complicating their compliance adherence.

Challenges in obtaining necessary insurance coverage for community transport services

One of the most pressing challenges facing community transport operators is acquiring adequate insurance coverage.

Due to their services’ undervalued nature compared to commercial providers, these operators struggle to meet the financial demands of comprehensive insurance policies.

The struggle intensifies in light of funding cuts, which compromises operators’ ability to secure insurance that encompasses the full scope of their services.

Community minibus schemes, which often run on tight budgets, face difficulty in securing insurance coverage financial constraints limit these organizations, especially when initiatives such as retrofitting vehicles to meet modern accessibility standards are necessary.

Adherence to accessibility standards for passengers with mobility challenges

Community transport services play a pivotal role in promoting independence for those with mobility challenges, removing the barrier to community activity and offering tailored door-to-door ride services.

These services operate under the premise of inclusivity, utilising fully accessible minibuses designed to accommodate modern wheelchairs. Fares are transparently based on journey length and are agreed upon in advance, reflecting the service’s commitment to fairness and accountability.

To maintain the high accessibility standards, passengers are required to be members of the scheme, ensuring that services cater specifically to those who truly require them—be it the elderly, disabled, or others who find public transport unsuitable for their needs.

The importance of providing access to essential services such as health appointments and shopping aids is immeasurable, reinforcing the role of community transport as a method of maintaining social connections and fostering individual autonomy.

Ensuring compliance with health and safety regulations for both passengers and staff

Community transport operators place passenger safety at the forefront of their operations, ensuring that all vehicles are fitted with seat belts and that drivers receive comprehensive MiDAS training.

This specialised training includes both theoretical classroom instruction and practical on-road driving assessments, designed to enhance safety on every trip.

Every four years, drivers must complete refresher training to maintain their MiDAS Certificate, demonstrating a commitment to sustained safety excellence and regulatory compliance.

Recommended:
Why Volunteer Drivers for Community Transport Deserve Free Parking

For passengers with disabilities, compliance extends to providing wheelchair-accessible vehicles and specialised driver training for proper handling and care.

The industry acknowledges the critical importance of safeguarding such passengers, particularly when considering the use of different modes of transportation throughout their journey.

Health and safety regulations must be rigorously upheld, not only to protect those on board but also to maintain the integrity and reputation of community transport services as a whole.

Social and Demographic Factors

social isolation community transport

Community transport provides a critical lifeline for those who reside in the societal margins, offering freedom and connection to elderly, disabled, financially disadvantaged individuals, and those isolated in remote areas denying them community engagement.

These services, flexible in nature, offer door-to-door transportation, specifically tailored to the varying needs of their clients. These transport services bridge gaps for social inclusion by ensuring that essential aspects of life, from healthcare to education and employment, remain within reach.

For those grappling with the constraints of conventional public transport, community transport becomes not just a conveyance but a gateway to an improved quality of life.

The undervaluing of community transport only exacerbates these challenges, overlooking the profound socio-demographic impact these services have on improving lives and facilitating equitable opportunities for all.

Isolation and connectivity issues faced by rural communities

Geographic separation and sparse population density are becoming a way of life for many in rural communities, often leading to a critical absence of mainstream public transport services.

This isolation is counteracted by the vital role that community transport schemes play, offering door-to-door services to connect residents to the outside world which is one of the benefits of community transport.

Whether it’s securing groceries, fulfilling health appointments, or simply reaching social events, these services are the threads weaving together the fabric of rural societies.

Addressing the connectivity conundrum, community transport acts as the arteries of mobility, without which these communities might otherwise be cut off, exacerbating social isolation and eradicating the opportunities that urban counterparts take for granted.

The presence of community transport schemes symbolises a commitment to ensuring that no individual is left behind due to the mere circumstance of geography.

An ageing population with increasing demand for medical appointments

As the demographics of communities shift towards an ageing populace, the reliance on community transport for accessing health services intensifies.

These services are not merely an added convenience but can become a determinant of life quality and health outcomes, especially for those residing in less accessible, often rural localities.

Unfortunately, many operators within this sector are bereft of public funding, creating a chasm in health equity for those reliant on community transport for medical appointments.

To mitigate this, some community transport initiatives provide free travel for the elderly and disabled, chipping away at the financial barriers preventing essential medical care mobility.

With ageing populations soaring, the call for regulatory support for these invaluable transport services has never been more pressing.

Limited public transport options in remote areas leading to reliance on community transport

In areas where the public transport map has blanks, community transport services step in to make their mark. Particularly in rural and isolated areas, the scarcity or outright absence of traditional bus and train services leaves residents with few options.

The erosion of England’s bus services has left older, non-driving populations at a disadvantage. But as conventional services recede, community transport initiatives press forward, addressing the resulting void with dial-a-ride programs, volunteer car schemes, and community buses.

These bespoke transportation options do more than move people; they connect them to life’s essentials and, by extension, to society itself. As public transport retracts, community transport expands, filling the spaces left behind with hope, access, and mobility for everyone.

Impact of community transport on social connections and community cohesion

Beyond just transit, community transport operators kindle social interactions and cohesiveness in the communities they service solving many community challenges that go beyond just the journey.

For the elderly in rural areas, community buses serve as a ‘third place’ where social ties are strengthened, combating the loneliness that can otherwise pervade. By building social capital, these services foster a sense of belonging and collective identity.

Recommended:
How Community Transport Services Keep Us All Connected

Transport accessibility through these services is crucial for those with disabilities or transportation disadvantages, paving the way for fuller participation in community life.

The wide-reaching implications of community transport touch on everything from personal welfare to regional policy, generating ripple effects that sustain not just individuals, but the communities in which they thrive.

Through their indispensable work, community transport operators and their caring communities, ensure that every journey taken is a step towards a more interconnected and inclusive tomorrow.

Operational and Administrative Challenges

admin staff issues road xs

Community transport schemes can encounter daunting operational and administrative challenges.

These obstacles stem from their mission to provide equitable transport services to those who are often overlooked by traditional public transport options.

One of the most pressing challenges is the increased demand due to the reduction of bus subsidies in rural areas.

This shift has left many older individuals, people with disabilities, and low-income groups with no alternative but to rely more heavily on these services.

Despite the mounting pressure, community transport operators are typically nonprofit organisations, depending heavily on volunteers and small local committees to orchestrate small-scale local transport services.

The foundational ethic of care that drives these schemes sees volunteers providing a skilled and heartfelt service, motivated by a desire to support their community rather than profit-making.

This spirit of altruism and the informal yet focused nature of community transport are what endear these services to those who depend on them.

Complex coordination of multiple community bus runs and routes

The coordination of community bus routes presents a unique challenge due to the highly personalised nature of the service.

Unlike commercial bus lines with fixed routes, community minibuses must plan their schedules based on active feedback and discussions with passengers.

This can involve a complex web of hospital appointments, geographical locations, and coordination with other local transport providers.

Each service—a community bus, Dial-a-ride, voluntary car scheme, or Demand Responsive Transport—must maintain its flexibility to cater to a community’s evolving needs.

Moreover, securing special permits and navigating traffic regulations add layers of complexity to this already intricate operation.

A Bright Future with Cutting-Edge Technology

road xs features and further information

The day-to-day administrative tasks for community transport operators can be overwhelming.

Managing bookings, keeping track of various schedules, and maintaining accurate passenger data demand considerable time and effort.

However, technological advancements in digital platforms and transport software such as Road XS, hold the promise of easing these burdens.

For instance, Road XS can:

  • Automate route planning and scheduling with its cutting-edge algorithm removing the manual work required to schedule trips and routes,
  • Find car scheme passengers the nearest available driver in a matter of seconds,
  • Connect communities, counties and islands with a standardised approach to bridge gaps providing collaboration between community transport providers so that they can work together effectively and support community hubs,
  • Provide drivers with pinpoint navigation to their pick-ups and destinations,
  • Ensure compliance with driver records management and reminders,
  • Provide in-depth reporting to secure future funding and win new contracts,
  • Identify areas of need for community transport previously unknown enabling provision of community transport services quickly,
  • Provide increased safety with GPS positioning integrated What3Words technology,

and lots more.

Never before has community transport had access to technology which enables them to get more done with existing resources but the challenge then often lies in training and getting people to adapt to more modern and new ways of working. It provides a “community infrastructure” to work better together in a secure and scalable way.

Road XS is built for people and removes a lot of the nervousness around technology thanks to how user-friendly it is to use.

When it comes to technology, things have never looked brighter for the community transport sector.

Summary

There are a number of challenges facing community transport despite community transport operators perform a crucial role, but they do so against a backdrop of significant operational and administrative challenges.

Finding solutions to these hurdles is vital not only for the sustainability of the services but for the continued well-being and social inclusion of the communities they serve.

We’re here to help because community transport matters.

Valuable insights straight to your inbox...

We'll send you the best of our posts straight to your inbox so you won't miss a thing!

Made for People…

Discover why transport operators are switching to Road XS

Send this to a friend